Articles / Guides
Songleading VS Performing
Barak Malichi
The difference between singing at people and helping people sing together.
The shift
Performing asks: how do I sound?
Songleading asks: are they singing with me?
That difference changes almost everything. It changes the key you choose, the tempo you start with, how much you explain, where you stand, how you use the microphone, and what you do when the room is not joining yet.
A performer can succeed even if the audience stays quiet. A songleader cannot. The music is only doing its job when the group starts to feel that the song belongs to them too.
What a songleader watches
A songleader watches the room while leading the song.
Are campers looking up? Are staff singing? Is the front row carrying everything while the back of the room is gone? Are people confused by the Hebrew? Is the tempo too fast for the words? Is the key comfortable for campers, or only comfortable for you?
These are musical questions and leadership questions at the same time.
Practical differences
- A performer may choose the impressive key. A songleader chooses the singable key.
- A performer may fill every space. A songleader leaves room for the group to enter.
- A performer may add complexity. A songleader removes friction.
- A performer may chase applause. A songleader chases participation.
- A performer may think about the next song. A songleader thinks about the next moment.
This does not mean songleading should be boring or small. It means your musical skill serves the group.
The real measure
After a strong songleading moment, people do not only say, "You sounded great."
They say, "We were singing."
That is the work.